Teams George Gilbert played for

Main FCMiddlesex (1851)
 New South Wales (1855/56-1874/75)
Other FCMarylebone Cricket Club and Metropolitan Clubs (1851)
 Surrey Club (1851)
 Gentlemen (1851)
MiscellaneousGentlemen of Surrey (1851)
 Gentlemen of New South Wales (1858/59)
 New South Wales and Victoria (1861/62)
 New South Wales (1861/62-1864/65)
 Albert Cricket Club (1863/64-1864/65)
 The World (1866/67)
 Newcastle (1876/77-1881/82)
 Northern Districts of New South Wales (1879/80)